Blasphemy, I know.
I got my RX-8 in late October 2009, as an alternate-driver when I wanted to drive something sportier than my VW Passat. The Passat had been a money pit, and I wanted a newer more reliable car (the RX-8 might seem like an odd choice for reliability, but it's actually been a champ), and since I had the flexibility of already owning a practical car, I went all-in on the RX-8 and got the manual transmission.
Shortly thereafter the Passat overheated due to frozen coolant in one of the coolant lines (who knew putting an un-insulated metal pipe RIGHT IN FRONT OF THE GRILLE would be a bad idea?), and the following summer it started refusing to start in hot weather -- like, turning the key did nothing, no clicks, no dimming dashboard lights, nothing. At that point I finally said "to hell with it", cut my substantial losses and trashed the Passat. The RX-8 has been my DD ever since.
I've taken it on a few 10-hour trips, but most of the 54,000 miles on it have been city miles, which means that I don't get to wring it out very often. Instead I get to feather the heavy clutch in traffic and do lots of rapid gear-changes pulling away from stoplights, and when I do get to sustain speed on the freeway I end up using the cruise-control to avoid getting tickets. So my left foot is tired and the drone from the exhaust on the freeway stays at the exact same pitch for long periods of time, which is somehow hypnotic and extremely annoying at the same time.
If I'd gotten the automatic I never would've learned to drive stick, but I also wouldn't have to put up with the constant frustration of driving this car in heavy traffic. Sure, the engine in the automatic is rated 20hp lower, but this engine has such a flat torque-curve that the only reason for the lower HP rating is because of the lower redline -- and since I almost never get close to redline anyway, I wouldn't miss the extra 20hp.
I wish I were better at predicting the future. In lieu of that, I wish I could trade for the automatic version without losing my shirt or taking a serious risk of buying an engine near the end of its lifespan. And I can't afford to buy a new car right now, so I'm stuck with what I've got. I never thought I'd hate this car, but circumstances conspired against me.
</rant>
Wishing I'd gotten the automatic